An Open Letter to the American People: Time to Put Amtrak Up for Sale

Since the middle of the 19th century until about 1920, when the popularity of the automobile began to shift the travel paradigm, nearly all intercity travelers in the U.S. moved by private rail car. The decline in private passenger rail transportation continued with the establishment of the National Highway System in the 1950s, and declined further as air travel became more prevalent. By the 1960s, with private rail bankruptcies increasing and a sustained decline in passenger rail travel, (buoyed in large part by cheap fuel prices) it became obvious to many that private railroads were becoming “the previous century’s mode of passenger rail transportation.”

Facing political cross-winds, and to avoid the total extinction of the passenger train, in 1970, Congress passed, and President Nixon signed into law, the Rail Passenger Service Act; and by 1971, Amtrak, as we now know it, began to operate intercity passenger rail travel as a hybrid public-private entity that receives taxpayer funding and is operated by the federal government. Today, however, subjected to increased passenger competition from automobiles, buses and airlines, insufficient capital resources and political bickering, Amtrak has once again come under scrutiny.

Yet, despite this, Amtrak’s ridership has maintained consistent growth, setting annual ridership records in seven of the last eight years. Fiscal 2010 ridership stood at 28.9 million and increased in January of this year to 94,000 more passengers than during the same period in 2010 – a six percent growth rate. With all of this as a backdrop, I now believe, however, it is time to put Amtrak back up for sale to the private sector. The writing is on the wall, and it says: “We need large scale intercity passenger rail travel in the last half of this century.”

This notion is fairly easy to predict and Amtrak will continue to play an integral role in the development of intercity passenger rail in the latter half of this century. As fuel prices continue to rise, more and more people will turn to rail transportation as an alternative to more energy consuming travel. In addition, as the airlines continue to condense their operations and eliminate smaller regional flights, travel options become less available. For instance, my hometown had 12 commuter flights a day just a few years ago. It is now reduced to two a day, with often only one on weekends, as the airlines concentrate on larger planes and long distance flights.

Yet, we have a beautiful 240,000-mile rail ROW network in North America that is already paid for and in much better condition than it was two decades ago. In most cases, this rail network connects all of our major center cities and ports, and passes closely by most major airports. It is also a fact that using the “steel wheel on steel rail” is vastly more fuel efficient than other modes…and new technologies like PTC and GPS provide for greater rail safety and convenience. Amtrak also has the national franchise to run intercity passenger trains, with a well-established route system of day trains and hotel trains. It has the right to use the freight railroad tracks. In addition, as the U.S. Postal Service struggles financially, more and more packages and mail are already being handled by freight forwarding companies. These are all valuable assets. But the question being bantered about is who should own and run Amtrak?

In my opinion, the two most logical companies to consider buying Amtrak are FedEx and UPS. FedEx, for example, bought the old Railroad Express Agency and operates their company under that charter. UPS talked to Amtrak several years ago about running express and packages on long distance schedule trains but did not pursue the project. There are other things happening in the transportation world that supports FedEx and UPS buying Amtrak. First, as mentioned, the commuter airline industry is disappearing rapidly as the airlines concentrate on jumbo jets and longer flights that skip many regional areas that FedEx and UPS already serve. You can’t fill the big planes with 20-30 small commuter planes and neither can UPS or FedEx fill their big planes with small ones. Take revenues from FedEx and UPS and add it to increasing intercity passenger rail revenues and you have a profitable venture!

To simplify things, Amtrak could be divided into two divisions, Eastern and Western, and sold or franchised to each of the express companies. Congress is trying to come up with a lot of infrastructure plans. Building two intercity passenger mail and express companies using the main lines of the existing railroad ROW’s creates a very safe and ethical 21st century network for moving people and packages.

My hat is off to FRA and the railroad people running Amtrak. They have kept our passenger trains alive and growing through a very difficult time. Previous head of Amtrak, Graham Claytor, was my mentor, and I know he is applauding current President and CEO Joe Boardman and his team for their fine work. Now, let’s help Amtrak, and the American travelers, move forward and prosper even more in the second half of the 21st century by selling it back to the private sector.

About these ads

5 Responses to An Open Letter to the American People: Time to Put Amtrak Up for Sale

  1. C. Jay Hadley says:

    I guess I was spoiled riding the New Haven Parlor cars, the NYC’s 20th Century Ltd. and many other “crack” trains. After watching express laden trains that often had more freight than pax cars your idea is ideal for a future mode of transportation in a sensible manner. It’s a shame the money that was literally poured out the window on the failed attempt that Amtrak made at buying and providing box cars for freight movement. Not even a court battle with the Union Pacific would hamper Amtrak’s efforts. Now the UP is holding the daily Chicago to LA run hostage over $750 million in “Improvements.” Yes, Joe Boardman is doing a superlative job but look what he’s facing. Every time we talk to Amtrak officials we hear, “We don’t have any money.” Just where are the billions that have been deposited into Amtrak’s piggy bank over 40 years gone? It seems like everyone in authority is treading water just to keep the operation running.
    I agree, its high time for 21st Century management of independent operators who want to make a profit in order to remain employed. God bless Graham Claitor as I don’t think we would even have an Amtrak system today if it wasn’t for his unselfish acts of trying to make Amtrak a sensible operation.

  2. gblatham says:

    40-sum-odd years ago, one of the typical arguments against the continued operation of passenger service by the Class Is was the presumed unfairness in forcing the freight side of our industry to underwrite varnish’s losses. Such an approach (supposedly?) undermined both capital investment and technological advancement, placed an undue burden upon shippers (by artificially inflating their freight rates) and captured funds which could have been used in other ways (including, to be perfectly candid, shareholder remuneration).

    Now, we’re supposed to believe that United Parcel and Federal Express, with eyes wide open, will freely _choose_ to “take revenues” generated by their currently profitable operations and dedicate that money to support intercity passenger train services? And Wall Street (et al) will simply sit back and watch it happen?!

    And precisely how would the Class Is benefit from all of this?

    Gil’s heart may be in the right pace, but I think he’s WAY off base.

    Garl Boyd Latham
    Dallas, Texas

    P.S. Joe “It’s-All-The-Long-Distance-Train’s-Fault” Boardman is NOT doing “fine work”!


  3. The bottom line is that there is latent demand to be filled, and lots of money to be made. It is the purview of government to facilitate, not obstruct, economic activity. How we make that happen is an open question.

  4. LoboSolo says:

    As a former employee at FedEx, I don’t see how rail would fit into their operations unless it was a maglev with spurs to their sorting facilities for their express freight. There would be SOME opportunity to use it for their slower services where they truck freight but I don’t kno if it would be worth the money.

    Aside from that, FedEx and UPS are interested in moving freight and not folks. Somehow I don’t think the existing freight rail companies would be happy to forced to share their rails with a company that gave lip service to passengers while focusing on freight.

    FedEx runs a limited sked to move freight and so the trains would have to fit in with that sked. Most of the domestic flights are in the wee hours of the morning. So I don’t think they’d be very interested in Amtrak.

  5. Hі, i think that і saw ʏou visited my website so i came to “return thе favor”.I am trying to find thingѕ to enhaոce my web site!I suppose its ok to use some
    of your ideas!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: